Thursday, June 9, 2011

Lightness and Strength


If you have flown any of the major airlines recently, you probably know about in-flight magazines.  In fact, there is a 70% chance that you have read at least an article or two of an American Way or Spirit magazine.  This type of magazine typically includes a "letter from the CEO" that tout;s the airline's economic security and strong customer service.  Many articles follow that feature various travel destinations and are dotted with advertisements for products like neck pillows, noise-cancelling head phones, and suitcases that are specifically geared towards airline travelers.

In the June 2011 issue of Continental's in-flight magazine, Hemispheres, the content was similarly predictable.  Inserted among interesting articles on seafood in Barcelona and olive oil in Spain were two separate, full-page advertisements for suitcases that grabbed my attention.  The first was for a German manufacturer named Rimowa.  The second was for Samsonite.  Each advertisement is strikingly different on multiple facets, but both portray the exact same message - lightness and strength.  I have compared and contrasted below:


1st Advertisement -  

  • black, gray, and white
  • lots of text - (lots of evidence/support)
  • concrete imagery - industrial
  • masculine themed


2nd Advertisement - 
  • bright colors
  • almost no text (3 words only) - no evidence
  • whimsical imagery - nature
  • feminine themed
Which ad persuades you?

No comments:

Post a Comment